Disable Preloader

CaseLaw

Giwa V. Ajayi (1993) SLR 7(F) (CA)

Brief

  • Libel; Ingredients
  • Privileged occasion and Defence of qualified privilege
  • Onus of proof of defamation
  • Significance of publication in defamation cases

Facts

The appellant sued all the respondents, as defendants, for libel claiming N1 million as damages. The appellant was at all material times a civil servant and controller of Low Cost Housing Projects with the Lagos State Development and Property Corporation. The respondents were staff and members of the Workers Union of the corporation.

The appellant's cause of action was founded on the minutes of a joint meeting between the management of the corporation and the defendants Union. The defendants represented their union.

Paragraph 4 of the plaintiff's statement of claim states as follows:

  • 4.
    The plaintiff avers that by Minutes of e said meeting of Friday, 10th June, 1983 at 10.30 am, the defendants falsely and maliciously published of concerning the plaintiff the words following, that is to say: A HOUSE AT ISOLO: The union alleged that one of our staff bought housing unit at Isolo, then put up a complete house within the housing unit using corporation's material and labour. The union alleged further that the corporation Internal Audit Department went into the mater sometime ago to investigate, but nothing was heard of the result of the investigation. When the chairman asked the name of the staff concerned it was disclosed as Alhaji K A Giwa, the controller of low cost Housing projects.

In their defence, the respondents pleaded that the averment in paragraph 4 of the statement of claim was true in substance and in fact. They also raised the defence of qualified privilege and supplied copious particulars of same. The appellant did not file a Reply.

The learned trial Judge after due hearing, in a considered judgment dismissed the appellant's claim the appellant was dissatisfied and he appealed to the Court of Appeal.

Issues

  • 1.
    "Whether the words complained of were published on a privileged...
    Read More